The Real Reason Joey Coan & Magda Szlachta Broke Up (Now A Surprising 90 Day Fiancé Cast Member Wants To Shoot His Shot)

90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days couple Joe “Joey” Coan and Magda Szlachta have shockingly split and the real reason has been revealed amid a surprising co-star wanting to date the Polish woman. Joey and Magda were first seen in Before the 90 Days season 7 as one of the eight couples. The dramatic season featured Tigerlily Taylor and Adnan Abdelfattah, Rayne Fernandez and Chidi Ikpeamaeze, Brian Muniz and Ingrid Rezende, Vanja Grbic and Božo Vrdoljak, Loren Allen and Faith Gatoc Tulod, Niles Valentine and Matilda Nti, and Veah Netherton and Sunny Mahdi, along with Joey and Magda.

Interestingly, Joey and Magda were among the three couples that stayed together after Before the 90 Days season 7. They were together at the Tell All, despite all the red flags in their storyline. Joey couldn’t even bother to say Magda’s name right. It said all that needed to be known about the seriousness of the relationship for the Florida man. It wasn’t surprising that Joey and Magda seemed to have parted on a bitter note. However, the news has made a controversial 90 Day Fiancé cast member want to date Magda. Has Magda shown interest in him too?

Joey & Magda’s 90 Day Fiancé Journey

What Happened Between Joey & Magda On 90 Day Fiancé?

Joey and Magda met when Joey was video chatting with a friend who was in Miami, and Magda was in the background, leading to a brief interaction that sparked a connection. Joey’s friend had passed the phone to Magda because she was driving, and the 90 Day Fiancé couple chatted briefly. Joey became smitten by Magda, but he then found out that she wasn’t from Miami as he thought. Magda was from Poland and was in the U.S. for a trip. She was on the way to the airport to fly home.

Joey and Magda stayed in touch despite her being in Poland. They soon started talking every day for hours. Joey described Magda as funny, smart, and having an “amazing” body. He expressed that he had never felt this way towards anyone before. Meanwhile, Magda was serious about getting married. She quit her job so she could live in America and have Joey’s children. Joey’s family became skeptical about her. They saw a lot of red flags in Magda from what he had said about her, and they felt that she could have been using him for a green card.

However, it was Joey who was the problem. Joeyy had cheated on Magda with an unknown woman just days after he connected with her. While Magda started wearing an engagement ring to let other men know she was taken and was saving herself until they got engaged, Joey wanted to take things slow before going exclusive. He had not told Magda that he had slept with a friend in his group. He had no qualms about being friends with his exes.

She screamed at him, “You f***ed your friend! You lied to me again.”

Joey had promised Magda that he would not lie to her ever again, but it seemed that every time she turned around, he was lying to her about women that he had slept with. At the Tell All, producers exposed Joey by sharing an unseen clip where a different friend of Joey’s revealed they had hooked up in the past. When Magda questioned him about it, he said, “Yeah, I’ve kissed her before, a while ago.” He kept insisting it was just a kiss and the woman wasn’t his ex-girlfriend.

Magda Confirmed Her Breakup With Joey

Magda Let Instagram Do The Talking

Joeyy didn’t think the information was relevant enough for him to share it with Magda. However, Magda needed time to process the new information. She told the producers that she didn’t trust Joey fully yet. The relationship seemed to be on shaky ground, but surprisingly, it did last for a couple of months before Joey and Magda completely ended it. The show premiered in November 2024, but the Tell All was filmed sometime in October 2024. Joey and Magda were no longer following each other by March 2025, and this sparked rumors of a breakup.

MerryPants shared a screenshot from Magda’s Instagram where a fan asked her, “How are you and Joeyy? So beautiful” and Magda replied to them with, “It’s true.” She deleted the comment, but a source confirmed with the blogger that Magda was back home and not a part of Joey’s recent birthday celebrations. The source confirmed that Magda and Joey’s relationship ended sometime in February 2025. “Joey had strong intentions for their future,” but Magda was looking for someone who was more aligned with her long-term goals and realized they were “simply incompatible.”

In April 2025, Shabooty revealed more proof of Joey and Magda’s split. He shared a screenshot of Magda’s Q&A session on Instagram. A fan asked her if she was still with Joey. Magda wrote, “no,” confirming they were done publicly. The blogger mentioned that Magda was in the U.S. with Joey but returned to Poland three months ago after their split. She’s seemingly declared that she will never do 90 Day Fiancé again and is “sick” of being asked about Joey. Moreover, Magda has also been “going through it” because her cat passed away recently.

Kyle Gordy Wants To Shoot His Shot With Magda

Who Is Kyle In 90 Day Fiancé?

Interestingly, now that Magda is seemingly single, she’s getting attention from her 90 Day Fiancé co-stars as well. Magda has not revealed if she is dating anyone yet. It even took her a while to admit that she and Joey had broken up. However, the post by Merrypants which had fans talking about how Magda deserves better and Joey was never the right man for her, there was one cast member who decided to shoot his shot. Kyle from 90 Day Fiancé: Love Is Paradise commented on the blogger’s post, revealing his true intentions about Magda.

*Me not stepping into her inbox.”

Kyle revealed that he was going to slide into Magda’s DMs after learning about her relationship status. Kyle wasn’t really a fan-favorite since his debut, when he introduced himself as a sperm donor who wishes to father over 100 kids by the end of the year. His partner on the show, Anika “Ani” Philipp, dumped him when he refused to give up inseminating his “clients” naturally. It doesn’t look like Kyle will be Magda’s type and, considering Kyle wants to date her to get on a new season, Magda has already made her intentions about 90 Day Fiancé clear.

90 Day Fiancé airs Sundays at 8 p.m. EDT on TLC.

Source: MerryPants/Instagram, Shabooty/Instagram